Movie Project #8: The Insider [1999]

Eric @ The Warning SignMovies22 Comments

50 Movies Project #4: Contemporary Edition

The 50 Movies Project is an annual tradition at The Warning Sign. Every year, I select 50 movies that I feel I must see in order to continue my progression as a film lover. This year I’m focusing on contemporary films (1980 to present day) that I somehow haven’t gotten around to seeing yet.

The Insider [1999]

The Insider [1999] Director: Michael Mann
Writer: Michael Mann, Eric Roth
Country: USA
Genre: Biography/Drama/Thriller
Starring: Russell Crowe, Al Pacino, Christopher Plummer
Running Time: 157 minutes

Whistleblowing reports are ripe for film adaptations, and Michael Mann’s The Insider turns one such true story into a gripping thriller. No action scenes are necessary here; instead, the film builds tension through the tumultuous work that is investigative journalism, and the extreme lengths large corporations will go to cover their asses.

Russell Crowe plays Dr. Jeffrey Wigand, a research chemist who decides to blow the whistle on the illegal behavior of his former employer, Brown & Williamson. Part of the triumvirate that is Big Tobacco, B&W had blatantly lied to Congress about the addictive nature of their cigarettes. Wigand is persuaded to spill the beans about these blatant perjuries by 60 Minutes producer, Lowell Bergman (Al Pacino).

There’s a lot on the line here. Wigand is breaking his confidentiality agreement, thereby risking jail, and he is receiving all sorts of legal pressure from his former company. He becomes paranoid, believing there to be threats on his life, and it begins to unravel his once-stable family. Bergman, determined to get this story out there, is fighting profusely with his superiors at CBS. They are worried about the possible financial repurcussions that could happen if they were to air an interview with Wigand. There’s a lot of back-and-forth drama going on, and the pressure takes its toll on both men. By the end of the film, both Wigand and Bergman look like they have been to hell and back. It’s an increasingly desperate battle between the evil corporation and those seeking to tell the truth.

The Insider [1999]

There is an equal emphasis on both men in this film. We grow to learn more about Wigand early on, as he battles with himself on whether or not to fully go through with his actions. Later, Bergman is the main focus as he fights tooth and nail to get the 60 Minutes interview with Wigand on the air and unedited. Even when things are looking absolutely dire, neither one gives up.

Both characters are well-written and given an ample amount of screen time, and Crowe and Pacino bring out the best in them. As the film goes on, it becomes more and more noticeable just how much of an uphill climb they have ahead of them. Crowe and Pacino are backed by an impressive supporting cast, including Christopher Plummer as 60 Minutes anchor Mike Wallace, Philip Baker Hall as the TV show’s top boss, and Diane Venora as Wigand’s distraught wife.

The Insider [1999]

If there is a flaw in the film, it’s the running time. This is a captivating story, no doubt, but it feels a bit stretched too thin to warrant a running time of over two and a half hours. There are moments where the film drags, and a bit more editing would have been beneficial.

In the end, The Insider asks the question: is justice really worth fighting for? In this case, yes, it appears so. All of the hard work from these two men did pay off, as the Big Tobacco companies reached a massive settlement (over $200 billion) with all 50 states. Wigand and Bergman emerged as different men by the end of it all, but it can be argued their perseverance made them stronger than they ever were before.

8/10

Eric @ The Warning SignMovie Project #8: The Insider [1999]

22 Comments on “Movie Project #8: The Insider [1999]”

  1. ruth

    Woo hoo! Glad you finally saw this, definitely a great slow-burn thriller from Michael Mann. Crowe should’ve won for his role here.

    P.S. Don’t forget Five for the Fifth later today ;)

  2. Nostra

    One of those movies I have been meaning to rewatch for a long time but still have not come around to yet. It has been so long since I have seen it that I can not remember anything about it.

  3. jjames36

    Great review, Eric. And I agree that this one seems a bit too long in places – which is a shame because so much of it is so brilliant (especially the performances).

  4. Dan Heaton

    This is one of my favorites from Michael Mann, who’s near the top for me with directors. I also love Bruce McGill’s big moment where he tears into the guy on the stand. So many great scenes across the board, and I love what Plummer does with Mike Wallace.

    1. Eric @ The Warning Sign

      Michael Mann is someone I really want to see more of. Aside from this film, I have seen Heat, Collateral and Public Enemies, and I liked all four (Heat being #1). The Last of the Mohicans was a last-minute cut from my project, but I hope to still catch it soon.

      1. Dan Heaton

        I’d watch the remainder in this order, though I like them all:

        Manhunter
        Ali
        Last of the Mohicans
        Thief
        Miami Vice (very underrated!)

        I haven’t seen The Keep or his TV movies, but I’d vouch for all of these. Heat is also my favorite, but it’s pretty close with a few others.

        1. Eric

          Awesome, thanks for the advice, Dan! I know at least a couple of these are on Netflix right now, so that’s a huge plus.

  5. Victor De Leon

    Nice job on this review, Eric! One of Mann’s strongest efforts and he was able to rein in Pacino and get an amazing performance from Crowe. All around, a great looking production with great material and a relevant moral dilemma at it’s core.

Leave a Reply